Image Source: www.gentrylocke.com
Essential Steps: How To Sue A Car Insurance Company Process
Can you sue a car insurance company? Yes, you can sue a car insurance company. People often sue their car insurance company when the company does not handle a claim fairly. This might happen after a car accident. The process of suing involves telling the company you think they did wrong, trying to fix it without court, and then going to court if needed. You usually need a lawyer to help you. This article tells you the steps.
Why People Sue Insurance Companies
You pay for insurance. You expect the company to help you when you need it. This is often after a car crash. The insurance company should pay valid claims. But sometimes they do not. Or they do not pay enough. Or they take too long. When this happens, you might need to sue them. This is often the last step. It happens when you cannot agree.
Many things can cause a problem.
* They might say your claim is not covered.
* They might offer you too little money.
* They might say the crash was your fault when it was not.
* They might ignore you.
* They might make unfair rules.
These problems can lead to big trouble for you. You might need money to fix your car. You might need money for doctor bills. If the insurance company does not pay, you suffer. This is why suing can be needed.
When Claims Go Wrong
Sometimes, things go wrong with an insurance claim. You file a claim after an accident. The company looks at it. They decide if they will pay. They decide how much they will pay. This is where problems start.
Denied Insurance Claim
A big reason people sue is a Denied insurance claim. You give the company all the details. You show them the damage. You show them the police report. You think your claim is clear. Then, the company says no. They deny your claim.
They might give a reason.
* They might say your policy does not cover the damage.
* They might say you did not report it fast enough.
* They might say the crash was not covered.
* They might say you lied.
Sometimes the reason is fair. But sometimes it is not. If you think they denied your claim for a bad reason, you can fight it. This can lead to a lawsuit.
Insurance Claim Dispute
Another reason for trouble is an Insurance claim dispute. This means you and the company do not agree. They might agree to pay something. But the amount is too low.
For example, your car repairs cost $5,000. The company says they will pay only $3,000. This is a dispute. You think they owe you $5,000. They think they only owe $3,000.
Disputes can also be about:
* Who was at fault in the accident.
* How much your car is worth.
* How much your injuries cost.
* How long you need a rental car.
You try to talk to them. You try to show them they are wrong. You might try Insurance adjuster negotiation. This is when you talk to the person handling your claim. You show them proof. You try to get them to change their mind. If talking does not work, the dispute continues.
Insurance Bad Faith
This is a very serious reason to sue. Insurance bad faith means the insurance company did not act fairly. They have a duty to you, their customer. They must handle your claim honestly. They must try to settle claims when it is fair to do so. If they do not, they might be acting in bad faith.
Examples of bad faith actions:
* Not trying to settle a claim when it is clear they should.
* Offering much less than the claim is worth without a good reason.
* Taking a very long time to handle a claim without a good reason.
* Not telling you why they denied a claim.
* Not investigating the claim properly.
* Threatening you.
* Making up reasons to deny a claim.
* Making you jump through too many hoops.
Suing for bad faith is different than just suing for a Denied insurance claim or Insurance claim dispute. If you win a bad faith lawsuit, you might get more than just the money for your claim. You might get extra money as punishment for the company. This is why Insurance bad faith lawsuits are serious.
Breach of Contract Insurance
Your insurance policy is a contract. It is a legal paper between you and the company. You agree to pay money (premiums). The company agrees to cover you in certain events. If the company does not do what the contract says they will do, this is a Breach of contract insurance.
For example, your policy says they will pay for damage from a crash. You have a crash. You file a claim. They refuse to pay. This might be a breach of contract. They broke their promise in the contract.
A lawsuit can be filed just for breach of contract. You ask the court to make the company follow the contract. You ask them to pay the money they owe you based on the contract rules.
Unfair Claims Practices
Many states have laws about how insurance companies must handle claims. These laws list things companies cannot do. These are often called Unfair claims practices.
These practices might include:
* Not settling claims quickly.
* Not telling you about all the parts of your policy.
* Changing the policy words to avoid paying.
* Asking for too much proof.
* Using low estimates for repairs or medical costs.
If a company does these things often, they might be breaking the law. This can be part of a Insurance bad faith lawsuit. It shows a pattern of acting unfairly.
What To Do Before You Sue
Suing is a big step. It takes time and money. You should try to fix the problem first. There are important steps to take before you file a lawsuit.
Gather All Your Papers
Get everything related to your claim.
* Your insurance policy paper.
* The claim number.
* Dates you talked to the company.
* Names of people you talked to (adjuster, agent).
* Copies of letters or emails you sent and got.
* Notes you took during phone calls.
* Photos of the damage.
* Repair estimates.
* Doctor bills or reports (if injuries happened).
* The police report from the accident.
* Receipts for things you paid for because of the accident (rental car, towing).
Keep everything in one place. This proof is very important later. It shows what happened. It shows what the company did or did not do.
Try Talking Again
Contact the company again. Write a formal letter. Explain why you disagree with their decision. Send copies of your proof. Clearly state what you want them to do. Send the letter by mail that tracks delivery. This shows you tried to fix it.
You can try Insurance adjuster negotiation again. Talk to the adjuster. Explain your position. Show them your proof. If the adjuster cannot help, ask to talk to their manager. Sometimes a supervisor can look at the claim fresh.
Keep notes of every talk. Who you talked to, the date, what was said.
Get Help From Your State
Some states have a department that watches insurance companies. This is often called the Department of Insurance. You can file a complaint with them.
Tell them what the company did. Show them your papers. They might look into your complaint. They might talk to the company. They might help you and the company talk. They cannot force the company to pay you money. But they can sometimes push the company to follow the rules. A complaint with the state can also be proof of Unfair claims practices later.
Deciding It Is Time to Sue
You tried talking. You sent letters. Maybe you filed a state complaint. The company still will not pay fairly. Or they still deny the claim. You feel stuck. This is when you think about suing.
Suing means you are taking the company to court. A judge or jury will hear both sides. They will decide who is right. This takes time. It takes money for court fees. It takes effort.
Before you decide, you should get advice. This is a key moment to Hire insurance lawyer.
Why Hire Insurance Lawyer
You need someone on your side who knows the rules. Insurance companies have lawyers. They handle claims and disputes all the time. They know the laws. You need help to stand against them.
A lawyer who handles insurance claims or car accidents is best. They know the tricks companies use. They know the laws about insurance. They know what your claim is really worth.
What a Lawyer Does For You
A lawyer helps you in many ways.
* Checks Your Case: They look at your papers. They tell you if you have a good case. They tell you what your rights are.
* Talks to the Company: They can talk to the company’s lawyers or high-level people. Sometimes a letter from a lawyer gets more attention.
* Knows the Value: They know how much your car is worth. They know how much doctor bills and pain are worth in a Personal injury lawsuit. They fight for the right amount.
* Handles the Rules: Court rules are complex. A lawyer knows these rules. They make sure papers are filed correctly.
* Gathers More Proof: They can get papers the company has. This is called discovery. This proof can show the company acted unfairly (Unfair claims practices, Insurance bad faith).
* Fights for You: They represent you in court. They speak for you. They argue your case.
* Negotiates: They try to reach a Car accident settlement for you. They know a good offer from a bad one.
Trying to sue an insurance company alone is very hard. They have a lot of power and knowledge. A lawyer balances this. It is very important to Hire insurance lawyer early in the process if you think you might sue.
How the Lawsuit Works: Litigation Against Insurance Company
When you cannot settle, the next step is Litigation against insurance company. This is the formal court process. It has many steps. It takes time.
Starting the Lawsuit
The lawsuit starts when your lawyer files papers with the court. This main paper is called a Complaint.
The Complaint tells the court:
* Who you are (the plaintiff).
* Who you are suing (the insurance company, the defendant).
* What happened (the accident, the claim).
* Why you are suing them (Denied insurance claim, Insurance bad faith, Breach of contract insurance, Unfair claims practices).
* What you want the court to make them do (pay you money, pay for damages, pay extra money for bad faith).
The court officially tells the insurance company they are being sued. This makes the lawsuit active.
Gathering Information: Discovery
This is a long part of the lawsuit. Both sides ask for and share information. This is called Discovery.
Types of Discovery:
* Written Questions: Both sides send written questions to the other side. You have to answer the company’s questions. They have to answer yours.
* Papers: Both sides ask for copies of papers. Your lawyer asks the company for claim files, emails, notes, and rules they follow. The company asks for your repair bills, medical records, wage loss papers. This is where your early record-keeping is very helpful.
* Talking Under Oath: This is called a deposition. A person answers questions from the other lawyer while a court reporter writes it all down. You might have to give a deposition. People from the insurance company might too. This is important for finding out what happened and finding proof of Insurance bad faith or Unfair claims practices.
Discovery is about getting all the facts out in the open. It helps both sides see the strengths and weaknesses of the case. It helps prepare for trial. It often shows if the company acted unfairly.
Asking the Court to Do Things: Motions
During the lawsuit, lawyers ask the judge to make decisions. These requests are called motions.
For example:
* A lawyer might ask the judge to make the other side give them papers they are holding back.
* A lawyer might ask the judge to throw out part of the case.
* After Discovery, one side might ask the judge to rule in their favor without a trial. This is called a motion for summary judgment. They argue that the proof is so clear, no trial is needed.
Motions help move the case forward. The judge decides them based on the law and the facts seen so far.
Trying to Settle Again
Even during a lawsuit, both sides often try to settle. A settlement is an agreement to end the case outside of court. The company agrees to pay you money. You agree to drop the lawsuit.
Settlement talks can happen at any time. Your lawyer talks to the company’s lawyer. They make offers. You decide if an offer is okay.
Sometimes, a judge or a neutral third person helps the talks. This is called mediation. A mediator does not decide who is right. They help the sides talk and find a way to agree. This can be a good way to reach a Car accident settlement without the risk and cost of a trial.
Going to Trial
If you cannot reach a Car accident settlement, the case goes to trial. A trial is where both sides present their case to a judge or a jury.
- Your lawyer presents your proof. They show papers, photos, maybe videos. They call people to speak (witnesses). You might speak. Your doctor might speak. An expert on car values might speak. They show why the company owes you money and why they acted wrongly (
Insurance bad faith,Breach of contract insurance). - The company’s lawyer presents their side. They show their proof. They call their witnesses. They try to show the company acted fairly and does not owe you more money.
- Both lawyers ask questions of the witnesses.
After hearing everything, the judge or jury makes a decision. This is called a verdict. If you win, the judge or jury decides how much money the company must pay you. This can include money for your damages and sometimes extra money if they find the company acted in bad faith.
What Kind of Lawsuit?
When you sue a car insurance company, your lawsuit is usually one of two main types, or sometimes both.
Lawsuit for Breach of Contract
This type of lawsuit says the company did not follow the rules in the insurance policy. You argue that the policy promised to cover something, but the company refused to pay. You ask the court to make them pay what the contract says they owe. This covers the cost of your car repairs, medical bills, lost wages, etc., up to your policy limits. It is about getting the money you were promised.
Lawsuit for Bad Faith
This type of lawsuit says the company acted unfairly or dishonestly when handling your claim. It is not just that they denied the claim, but how they handled it. You argue they broke their duty to act fairly towards you. If you win a bad faith lawsuit, you can get the money owed under the policy plus extra money. This extra money might cover the harm caused by their bad actions (like stress or financial loss) and sometimes money to punish the company and stop them from doing it again.
These lawsuits often happen together. For example, you might sue saying the company breached the contract by not paying your claim, and also that they acted in bad faith in how they denied it or handled the Insurance claim dispute.
How Long Does It Take?
Suing an insurance company takes time. It is not a quick fix.
* Trying to settle before suing: Weeks to months.
* The lawsuit process itself (discovery, motions, talks): Many months, often a year or two.
* Going to trial: The trial itself might be days or a week, but getting to trial takes a long time.
The total time from when you file the lawsuit to when it is over (by settlement or trial) can easily be one to three years, or even longer in complex cases or if there are appeals after trial.
How Much Does It Cost?
Suing costs money.
* Court fees to file papers.
* Cost of getting copies of papers.
* Cost of depositions (court reporter, video).
* Cost of expert witnesses (like doctors or car experts) to explain things.
* Lawyer fees.
Most people cannot pay these costs as they go. Many lawyers take insurance lawsuit cases on a “contingency fee” basis. This means the lawyer gets paid a percentage of the money you get from a settlement or trial win. If you do not win, the lawyer does not get paid their fee (though you might still have to pay some case costs). This makes it possible for people to hire a lawyer even if they do not have a lot of money upfront. It is very important to talk to your lawyer about costs and fees at the start.
What About Settlement?
Most lawsuits against insurance companies do not go to trial. They end in a Car accident settlement. Settlement can happen at any point. It can happen soon after filing the lawsuit. It can happen right before trial starts.
Why settle?
* Avoids Risk: Trial has a winner and a loser. You might get nothing at trial. Settlement guarantees you some money.
* Saves Time: Settlement ends the case faster than trial.
* Saves Money: Settlement costs less than trial costs.
* Privacy: Settlement details are usually private. Trial is public.
Your lawyer’s job includes trying to get a good Car accident settlement for you. They use the proof gathered during Discovery to show the insurance company why they should pay more. Insurance adjuster negotiation continues, but now between lawyers. Your lawyer advises you on settlement offers. You decide if you accept or reject an offer.
If It Goes To Trial
If no settlement is reached, you go to trial. Trial is the formal hearing before the court. It is serious. It takes a lot of work from your lawyer.
Your lawyer presents your case. They use all the proof they gathered. They argue the law. They try to show that the insurance company did not handle your claim correctly. They explain your damages – the money you need for repairs, medical care, lost work, pain and suffering, and possibly extra money if Insurance bad faith is proven.
The insurance company’s lawyer presents their case. They try to show they acted fairly. They try to reduce the amount of money you could get.
The judge or jury listens to everything. They make a decision based on the law and the facts.
What Might Happen Next?
After a trial, there is a decision.
* You Win: The court orders the insurance company to pay you money. The amount could be what you asked for, less, or sometimes more, especially in a bad faith case.
* You Lose: The court says the insurance company does not owe you more money.
* Appeal: The side that loses might ask a higher court to review the decision. This is called an appeal. Appeals take more time and money.
If you settled, the company sends the settlement money. Your lawyer pays off any case costs, medical bills (if your settlement included them), and takes their fee. You get the rest.
Suing When Injured
If the car accident caused injuries, your claim against the insurance company likely includes a Personal injury lawsuit part. This means you are asking for money to cover:
* Doctor and hospital bills.
* Money lost from not being able to work.
* Pain and suffering.
* Other costs because of the injury.
When you sue the insurance company over a Personal injury lawsuit claim, the company’s duty to handle the claim fairly is still key. If they refuse to pay valid medical bills or offer very little for serious injuries, this can be part of your reason to sue them. The lawsuit then covers both the unfair claim handling and the money needed for your injuries. The Car accident settlement or trial win would include money for your injury costs.
Final Things to Consider
- Time Limits: There are time limits for filing lawsuits. This is called the statute of limitations. If you wait too long, you lose your right to sue. A lawyer knows these time limits.
- State Laws: Insurance laws are different in each state. What is
Insurance bad faithin one state might be different in another. A local lawyer knows your state’s laws. - Your Policy: Read your policy. Know what it covers. Know the rules. This helps you know if the company is breaking the rules (
Breach of contract insurance). Your lawyer will read it carefully too.
Suing a car insurance company is a serious step. It means you believe the company did not treat you right. It is a way to make them follow their contract and act fairly. It is a complex process, full of rules and steps like discovery, motions, and possibly trial. Getting help from a good lawyer is almost always needed to guide you through Litigation against insurance company and fight for your rights.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
h4 What counts as insurance bad faith?
Insurance bad faith happens when your insurance company does not handle your claim fairly or honestly. Examples are refusing to investigate a claim, delaying payment for no good reason, offering a lot less money than the claim is worth, or not telling you why they denied your claim. It means they broke their duty to act in good faith towards you, their customer.
h4 Can I sue if my claim was just denied, even if it’s not bad faith?
Yes, you can sue if your Denied insurance claim was a Breach of contract insurance. This means you believe the insurance policy says they should pay the claim, but they refused. You are suing to make them follow the contract and pay the money they owe you under the policy rules. This is different from a bad faith claim, which is about how they handled the denial.
h4 How long does a lawsuit against an insurance company take?
It can take a long time. From filing the lawsuit to finishing through settlement or trial, it often takes one to three years. Complex cases or appeals can take even longer.
h4 How much does it cost to sue an insurance company?
Costs include court fees, getting copies of papers, and paying experts. Lawyer fees are usually the biggest cost. Many lawyers take these cases on a contingency fee. This means they get paid a part of what you win, and they don’t get a fee if you lose. You might still have to pay case costs even if you lose, but this is something to discuss with your lawyer.
h4 Do I need a lawyer to sue my car insurance company?
It is highly recommended to Hire insurance lawyer. Insurance laws are complex, and insurance companies have their own lawyers. Fighting them alone is very hard. A lawyer knows the process (Litigation against insurance company), your rights, the value of your claim, and how to fight against Unfair claims practices or Insurance bad faith.
h4 Can I negotiate with the insurance adjuster myself before suing?
Yes, you should try Insurance adjuster negotiation first. Present your evidence and explain why you disagree with their offer or denial. Keep good records of these talks. If you cannot agree after trying to negotiate, then you might consider suing.
h4 What is a car accident settlement?
A Car accident settlement is an agreement between you and the insurance company (or the other driver’s insurance company) to resolve a claim or lawsuit without going to trial. You agree to accept a certain amount of money, and in return, you give up your right to sue or continue the lawsuit. Settlements can happen at any time, even after a lawsuit starts.
h4 What is a personal injury lawsuit related to this?
If your car accident caused injuries, you might file a Personal injury lawsuit to get money for medical bills, lost wages, pain, and suffering. If your own insurance company is not handling your injury claim fairly (maybe because of slow payment or low offers), suing them might involve both your injury claim and their unfair handling of it (bad faith).
h4 What are unfair claims practices?
These are actions by an insurance company that state laws say are not allowed when handling claims. Examples include not settling claims quickly, not investigating claims fully, or using unfair standards to decide how much to pay. These practices can be proof in an Insurance bad faith lawsuit.
h4 What if the lawsuit goes to trial?
If you do not settle, your case goes to trial. Both sides show their proof and speak to a judge or jury. The judge or jury makes a decision (a verdict) about whether the company owes you money and how much. Trial is the last step if no agreement is reached earlier.
h4 What evidence do I need to sue my insurance company?
You need all papers related to your claim: your policy, claim number, dates of talks, names of people you spoke to, letters, emails, notes, photos of damage, repair estimates, medical bills/reports (if injured), police report, and receipts for costs. This proof helps show what happened and how the company acted. Your lawyer will also gather more evidence during the lawsuit process.