Yes, you can sue a car insurance company. You can take legal action against insurance company if they fail to uphold their end of the contract, especially if they unfairly deny your car insurance claim or handle your claim in bad faith insurance claim. Filing a lawsuit against insurance company is often a last step when other attempts to resolve a dispute have failed.
Image Source: jknylaw.com
Grasping Your Right to Sue Your Insurer
When you buy car insurance, you enter a contract. You agree to pay premiums. The insurance company agrees to protect you. They promise to handle claims covered by your policy. They also promise to handle claims fairly and promptly.
But sometimes, things go wrong. The company might not pay a valid claim. They might delay paying for a long time. They might offer you much less money than your claim is worth. When the insurance company refuses to pay what they owe based on your policy terms, you have the right to dispute it.
If the company still doesn’t act fairly after you try to work things out, you might need to sue them. A lawsuit is a formal way to ask a court to make the insurance company follow the contract. It’s a serious step. But it can be needed to get the money you are owed.
Why Insurance Companies May Deny Claims
Insurance companies don’t pay every claim. They have reasons for denying claims. Some reasons are valid. Others may not be. Knowing why they deny claims helps you know if their denial is fair.
Here are some common reasons an insurance company might give for a denied car insurance claim:
- No Coverage: The event or damage is not covered by your specific policy. For example, your policy might not cover flood damage, and your car was flooded.
- Policy Limits: Your claim is for more money than your policy covers for that type of damage or injury. The company will only pay up to your limit.
- Lapsed Policy: Your policy was not active when the accident happened. You might have missed a payment.
- Fault Dispute: The insurance company might say the accident was your fault, or mostly your fault, and your policy doesn’t cover damage you cause, or they are trying to avoid paying the other party.
- Lack of Proof: You didn’t provide enough proof of the damage, your injuries, or how the accident happened.
- Late Reporting: You waited too long to report the claim based on the rules in your policy.
- Exclusions: Your policy lists certain things it will not cover, and your claim falls under one of these exclusions. For example, using your personal car for ridesharing might be excluded.
- Fraud Suspicion: The company thinks your claim is not real or that you are lying about something.
- Disagreement on Value: For a totaled car, they might offer a value you think is too low. For repairs, they might disagree on the cost or method of repair.
Some denials are fair based on your policy. But sometimes, an insurance company uses these reasons unfairly to avoid paying. This is when a denied car insurance claim can become a legal fight.
Deciphering Bad Faith Insurance Claims
A major reason people sue insurance companies is for bad faith. Bad faith is more than just denying a claim. It means the insurance company acted dishonestly or unfairly when handling your claim. They failed to act in good faith towards you, their customer.
Insurance companies have a duty to handle claims reasonably and quickly. They must investigate claims properly. They must try to settle claims where they clearly owe money. When they don’t do these things, they might be acting in bad faith.
Examples of actions that might be considered a bad faith insurance claim:
- Unreasonable Delays: Taking too long to investigate or pay a claim without a good reason. They might “string you along.”
- Poor or No Investigation: Not doing a proper job of looking into your claim to figure out what happened and how much is owed.
- Refusing to Settle When They Should: Refusing to pay a claim when it’s very clear they are responsible under the policy terms. This is a form of insurance company refusing to pay.
- Offering Far Less Than the Claim is Worth: Making a “lowball” offer knowing the real value of the claim is much higher. This leads to an insurance settlement dispute.
- Misrepresenting Policy Language: Lying to you about what your policy covers or doesn’t cover.
- Using Threats or Pressure: Trying to pressure you into accepting a low offer or dropping your claim.
- Requesting Needless Information: Asking for documents or information they don’t really need, just to delay the process.
- Changing the Reason for Denial: Giving one reason for denial, then changing it later when you challenge the first reason.
Acting in bad faith breaks the insurance contract and state laws. If you can prove the insurance company acted in bad faith, you can sue them not just for the money they owed you under the policy, but potentially for extra damages too.
Common Situations Leading to a Lawsuit
Several specific scenarios can make suing an insurance company necessary. These often start with a claim dispute.
Denied Car Insurance Claim
As mentioned, a denied claim is a primary trigger. This happens when you file a claim for damage to your car or for injuries after an accident, and the company says “no.”
This denial can be for various reasons:
- They say the damage happened before the accident.
- They claim the accident wasn’t as severe as you say.
- They argue you were mostly or entirely at fault, even if evidence suggests otherwise.
- They say a certain part of your car or type of injury isn’t covered.
- They deny a claim because you didn’t follow a specific procedure they required.
If you believe their denial is wrong or unfair, you can dispute it. If they stick with the unfair denial, this is when you might think about filing a lawsuit against insurance company.
Insurance Company Refusing to Pay
This is closely linked to denial but can also involve delay. The insurance company might not outright deny the claim but just not pay it.
This includes:
- Excessive delays in processing your claim.
- Taking months or even years to investigate a simple accident.
- Making excuses for why they haven’t paid or offered a settlement.
- Not responding to your calls or emails about your claim.
An insurance company refusing to pay a valid claim within a reasonable time can be a form of bad faith. State laws often require claims to be handled within certain timeframes. If they miss these deadlines without good cause, you might have grounds for legal action against insurance company.
Insurance Settlement Dispute
Sometimes the insurance company agrees to pay, but the amount is the problem. They might offer you a settlement that is much lower than what you need to fix your car or pay your medical bills.
An insurance settlement dispute arises when:
- They offer far less than the market value for your totaled car.
- They offer less than the estimated cost to repair your car properly.
- They offer too little money to cover your medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering from injuries.
- They ignore future medical needs or ongoing pain.
If their offer is unreasonably low, especially when compared to clear evidence of your losses, it can be a sign they are not negotiating fairly. This dispute can escalate to a point where a lawsuit is needed to get a fair amount.
Delays in Processing or Investigation
Time is important after an accident. You need your car fixed or replaced. You need medical treatment. Long delays by the insurance company can cause real hardship.
Unreasonable delays might include:
- Taking weeks to assign an adjuster.
- Waiting months for an adjuster to inspect the damage.
- Dragging out the investigation of fault without a clear reason.
- Delaying payment after a settlement amount has been agreed upon.
Many states have rules about how quickly insurance companies must handle claims. If delays are excessive and without good reason, it can be evidence of bad faith, allowing you to pursue a car accident insurance claim lawsuit.
Disputes Over Fault
Insurance companies spend a lot of time figuring out who was at fault in an accident. This is because fault often determines who pays. If the company wrongly finds you mostly at fault, they might deny your claim or reduce the amount they pay significantly.
If you were hit by another driver, and that driver’s insurance company blames you instead of their driver, this creates a dispute. If your own insurance company doesn’t fight hard enough for you against the other insurer, or even agrees you were at fault when you weren’t, this can also lead to problems.
Proving fault often requires gathering evidence like police reports, witness statements, and photos of the accident scene. If the insurance company ignores clear evidence that favors you, their handling of the fault determination could be a reason to consider legal action.
Legal Action Against Insurance Company: The Process
Taking legal action against an insurance company is a formal process. It starts long before you ever go to court. Here’s a simplified look at the steps involved.
First, you usually try to resolve the issue directly with the insurance company. You might write letters, send emails, and call them. You present your evidence and explain why you disagree with their decision.
If that doesn’t work, you might use the company’s internal appeals process, if they have one. This means asking a different person or department within the company to review your claim.
If these steps fail and you still believe the company is treating you unfairly, you might consider legal action.
When to Consider an Insurance Dispute Lawyer
Dealing with an insurance company that is denying or delaying a claim can be very stressful. They have adjusters and lawyers who know insurance rules very well. You might feel outmatched.
This is where an insurance dispute lawyer can help a lot. They understand insurance law. They know the tactics companies use. They can evaluate your situation and tell you if you have a good case to fight the company.
A lawyer can:
- Review your policy and the company’s reasons for denial or delay.
- Gather evidence to support your claim.
- Communicate with the insurance company on your behalf.
- Negotiate for a fair settlement.
- Determine if the company acted in bad faith.
- Guide you through the process of filing a lawsuit against insurance company if needed.
They can help level the playing field and increase your chances of getting a fair outcome. Many lawyers who handle these cases work on a contingency fee basis. This means they only get paid if they win your case, and their fee is a percentage of the money you receive. This can make it possible to hire a lawyer even if you don’t have money upfront.
Filing a Lawsuit Against Insurance Company
If negotiations and appeals fail, your lawyer might advise filing a lawsuit. This is the formal step of taking your case to court.
Here are the basic steps in filing a lawsuit:
- Drafting the Complaint: Your lawyer prepares a document called a complaint. This document explains who you are suing (the insurance company), why you are suing them (e.g., breach of contract, bad faith), what happened, and what you are asking the court to do (usually, order the company to pay you money).
- Filing with the Court: The complaint is filed with the proper court. The court case officially begins.
- Serving the Lawsuit: The insurance company must be formally notified that they are being sued. This is called “service of process.” They receive a copy of the complaint.
- The Insurance Company’s Answer: The company must respond to the complaint within a specific time. They file a document called an answer, where they state whether they agree or disagree with each point in your complaint and present their defenses.
Filing the lawsuit starts the formal legal process. It shows the insurance company you are serious about pursuing your claim.
Car Accident Insurance Claim Lawsuit
Many lawsuits against car insurance companies stem from car accidents. After a crash, you might file a claim for damage to your car, medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. This is often called a personal injury claim against insurance.
A car accident insurance claim lawsuit might happen if:
- Your own insurance company unfairly denies your collision or comprehensive claim for vehicle damage.
- Your own uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage claim is denied or undervalued after you were hit by a driver without enough insurance.
- The other driver’s insurance company refuses to pay for your vehicle damage or personal injuries, or offers a settlement amount that is far too low, leading to an insurance settlement dispute.
In these cases, the lawsuit usually involves proving the other driver was at fault (if you’re suing their insurer) and proving the full extent of your damages (car repairs/replacement, medical costs, lost income, suffering). If you are suing your own insurer, you prove the loss is covered and they failed to pay. If suing for bad faith, you must prove they handled the claim unfairly.
Personal Injury Claim Against Insurance
If you were injured in a car accident, you will likely file a personal injury claim against the at-fault driver’s insurance. If the at-fault driver has no insurance or not enough insurance, you might file a claim with your own insurance company under your uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage.
A personal injury claim against insurance often involves:
- Gathering all your medical records and bills.
- Calculating lost wages if you missed work because of injuries.
- Putting a value on your pain and suffering.
- Negotiating with the insurance adjuster.
If the insurance company for either the at-fault driver or your own insurer refuses to pay a fair amount for your injuries, you might need to file a lawsuit. This type of lawsuit specifically seeks money to cover all your injury-related costs and impacts.
Building Your Case: Proof is Key
Winning a lawsuit against an insurance company requires strong proof. You need to show the court that the insurance company did not fulfill its duties under the policy or acted in bad faith.
Evidence to support your case can include:
- Your Insurance Policy: This is the contract. It shows what is covered and the company’s obligations.
- Claim Documents: All papers related to your claim, such as the initial claim form, repair estimates, photos of damage, police report, witness statements, and medical records.
- Communication Records: Keep copies of everything. Emails, letters, notes about phone calls (who you spoke to, when, what was said). This is crucial for showing delays or unfair statements made by the adjuster.
- Photos and Videos: Pictures of the accident scene, vehicle damage, your injuries. Videos from dashcams or security cameras.
- Witness Information: Names and contact details of anyone who saw the accident or can speak about your damages or injuries.
- Expert Opinions: Sometimes you need experts, like a mechanic to talk about vehicle value, a doctor to explain your injuries and future needs, or even an insurance expert to explain how claims should be handled.
If you are claiming bad faith, you need proof of the insurance company’s actions. This means showing evidence of unreasonable delays, unfair offers, poor investigation, or misleading statements. Your detailed log of communications with the adjuster is very important here.
Your lawyer will help you gather and organize this evidence.
What You Can Sue For
When you sue a car insurance company, you can ask the court to award you different types of money or relief.
- Contract Damages: This is the amount the insurance company should have paid you under the policy in the first place. For a property damage claim, it’s the cost of repairs or the value of the car. For a personal injury claim, it’s medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering up to the policy limits.
- Extra Damages for Bad Faith: If you prove the insurance company acted in bad faith, you can potentially recover more than just the policy amount. This might include:
- Consequential Damages: Money for losses you suffered because of the bad faith delay or denial. This could be extra costs incurred because your car wasn’t fixed, lost income from being unable to work, or even costs associated with having to hire a lawyer to fight them.
- Emotional Distress: Money for the stress, anxiety, and emotional hardship caused by the insurance company’s unfair actions.
- Punitive Damages: In cases of severe or malicious bad faith, the court might award punitive damages. This money is not to compensate you for a loss, but to punish the insurance company for their behavior and to deter them and other companies from acting this way in the future. Punitive damages are not common and depend heavily on state law and the specific facts of the case.
- Legal Fees and Costs: In some states, if you win a bad faith case, the insurance company may be ordered to pay your legal fees and court costs. This helps you recover the money you spent fighting them.
The specific types and amounts of money you can sue for depend on the details of your case, the terms of your insurance policy, and the laws in your state. An insurance dispute lawyer can explain what you might be able to recover.
Interpreting the Role of an Insurance Dispute Lawyer
Choosing to sue your insurance company is a big decision. It involves complex legal rules and procedures. This is where an insurance dispute lawyer becomes invaluable. They don’t just file papers; they guide you through the entire process.
Here’s how an insurance dispute lawyer helps:
- Case Evaluation: They listen to your story, review your documents, and tell you if you have a strong case against the insurance company. They can spot bad faith behavior you might not recognize.
- Negotiation: Before filing a lawsuit, they often try to negotiate with the insurance company on your behalf. A letter or call from a lawyer is often taken more seriously than calls from the policyholder alone. They can push for a fair insurance settlement dispute resolution.
- Gathering Evidence: They know what evidence is needed to prove your claim and bad faith. They can gather official reports, speak to witnesses, and get expert opinions.
- Navigating the Law: Insurance law and court procedures are complicated. A lawyer understands these rules. They know the deadlines, how to file documents correctly, and what to do at each stage of a lawsuit.
- Litigation: If a settlement isn’t reached, they represent you in court. This includes handling discovery (swapping information with the other side), motions, and potentially a trial.
- Maximizing Recovery: They fight to get you the full amount you are owed under your policy, plus any extra damages if the company acted in bad faith.
Finding the right lawyer for your specific type of case (like a car accident insurance claim lawsuit or a personal injury claim against insurance) is important. Look for lawyers who focus on insurance disputes or personal injury cases.
How to Sue an Insurance Company: Step-by-Step (Simplified)
Thinking about how to sue an insurance company? Here’s a basic breakdown of the typical steps. Remember, a lawyer handles most of these steps for you once you hire them.
- Gather Your Documents: Collect your insurance policy, claim number, all correspondence with the insurance company (letters, emails, notes from calls), claim denial letter or low settlement offer, repair estimates, medical bills, police reports, photos, etc. Everything related to your claim.
- Attempt to Resolve Informally: Before suing, make sure you’ve clearly communicated with the insurer why you disagree with their decision. Send a formal letter explaining your position and providing supporting evidence. Ask for a full review of your claim.
- Consult with a Lawyer: Talk to an insurance dispute lawyer. Bring all your documents. They will review everything and tell you if you have a valid case for legal action against insurance company. This is a crucial step.
- Lawyer Contacts Insurer: Your lawyer will likely send a demand letter to the insurance company, outlining your case and demanding a fair settlement. This is often a final attempt to settle before filing a lawsuit.
- File the Lawsuit: If the company does not respond reasonably to the demand letter, your lawyer will prepare and file a complaint with the court. This formally begins the lawsuit. This is the step of filing a lawsuit against insurance company.
- Discovery: This is a major phase where both sides exchange information. Your lawyer will ask the insurance company for documents and question their employees (depositions). The insurance company will do the same to you. This helps both sides learn more about the case.
- Negotiation and Mediation: Lawsuits often settle before trial. Negotiations happen throughout the process. Sometimes, a neutral third party (a mediator) helps both sides try to reach an agreement. An insurance settlement dispute can often be resolved here.
- Trial: If no settlement is reached, the case goes to trial. Both sides present their evidence and arguments to a judge or jury, who will then make a decision.
- Judgment or Appeal: If you win at trial, the court issues a judgment ordering the insurance company to pay you. The company might then appeal the decision to a higher court.
This process can take a long time, sometimes a year or more, depending on the complexity of the case and court schedules.
Weighing the Pros and Cons of a Lawsuit
Suing your car insurance company is not a decision to make lightly. There are good points and bad points to consider.
Pros:
- Getting the Money You Deserve: A lawsuit can be the most effective way to force the insurance company to pay the full amount owed under your policy or a fair value for your losses.
- Holding the Insurer Accountable: A lawsuit, especially one alleging bad faith, can hold the company responsible for unfair practices. This can be important not just for you but potentially for other policyholders.
- Potential for Extra Money: If you prove bad faith, you might recover more than just the original claim amount, including damages for your trouble and potentially punitive damages.
- Resolution: While lengthy, a lawsuit provides a path to a final resolution, either through settlement or a court decision.
Cons:
- Time: Lawsuits take time. It can be many months or even years from filing the complaint to a final resolution.
- Cost: Although many lawyers work on contingency for car insurance disputes, there are still court costs, filing fees, and costs for gathering evidence (like paying for medical records or expert witnesses). If your lawyer works on contingency, you usually don’t pay legal fees unless you win, but you might still be responsible for some costs.
- Stress: Being involved in a lawsuit can be emotionally draining and stressful.
- Uncertain Outcome: There is no guarantee you will win. The court might side with the insurance company.
- Impact on Future Insurance: Suing your insurer could potentially affect your ability to get insurance in the future, although companies are generally not allowed to retaliate just for filing a valid claim or dispute.
Discussing these points honestly with an insurance dispute lawyer is important to decide if suing is the right path for you.
Alternatives to Suing
Suing is a powerful tool, but it’s not the only option if you have a dispute with your car insurance company.
Other avenues to explore include:
- Internal Appeals: Use the insurance company’s own process to have a manager or different adjuster review your claim decision.
- State Insurance Department Complaint: You can file a formal complaint with your state’s Department of Insurance. This government agency regulates insurance companies. They won’t order the company to pay your claim, but they can investigate whether the company followed insurance laws and handled your claim properly. A complaint from the state can sometimes pressure the insurance company to re-evaluate your claim.
- Mediation or Arbitration: Some policies have clauses requiring mediation or arbitration. These are ways to resolve disputes outside of court with the help of a neutral third party. Even if not required, you and the insurance company can agree to mediation or arbitration voluntarily to avoid a lawsuit.
- Negotiation: Keep trying to negotiate with the insurance company or work with a lawyer to negotiate on your behalf before filing suit.
These alternatives can be faster and less costly than a lawsuit. However, if the insurance company is firmly refusing to budge or acting in bad faith, a lawsuit might be the only way to get justice.
In conclusion, you absolutely can sue a car insurance company, especially if they have unfairly denied your claim, delayed payment unreasonably, offered a low settlement, or otherwise acted in bad faith. While the process of filing a lawsuit against insurance company can be long and complex, it is sometimes necessary to protect your rights and recover the money you are owed after a car accident or other covered event. Getting advice from an insurance dispute lawyer is highly recommended to understand your options and decide the best way forward.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
H4: How Long Does it Take to Sue an Insurance Company?
It varies a lot. Simple cases might settle within a few months after a lawsuit is filed. More complex cases, especially those involving significant injuries or allegations of bad faith, can take one to two years or even longer to resolve, especially if they go to trial.
H4: How Much Does it Cost to Sue an Insurance Company?
Many lawyers who handle car insurance claim lawsuits or personal injury claims against insurance work on a contingency fee. This means the lawyer gets a percentage of the final settlement or court award. You usually don’t pay upfront legal fees. However, you might still be responsible for court filing fees, costs for getting documents (like medical records), and expert witness fees, which can add up. Your lawyer will explain their fee structure and costs.
H4: Can I Sue for a Small Claim?
Whether it’s worth suing depends on the amount in dispute and the complexity. For very small claim disputes (a few hundred dollars), the time and cost of a lawsuit might not be worth it. However, even a seemingly small denial could involve bad faith practices that affect many people. A lawyer can advise if your specific situation warrants legal action. Small claims courts might be an option for smaller amounts, but rules vary by state.
H4: Will Suing My Insurer Cancel My Policy?
Insurance companies generally cannot cancel your policy just because you filed a claim or sued them in good faith. They can decide not to renew your policy when it expires, especially if you become a high-risk customer due to the number or type of claims. However, retaliatory cancellation solely for filing a lawsuit over a dispute is usually against the law.
H4: What is Bad Faith Insurance Claim?
A bad faith insurance claim is when an insurance company fails to handle a claim fairly and honestly, breaching its duty to the policyholder. Examples include unreasonable delays, denying claims without a proper investigation, or refusing to pay a valid claim when their responsibility is clear.
H4: What is an Insurance Dispute Lawyer?
An insurance dispute lawyer is a lawyer who helps policyholders resolve conflicts with their insurance companies, whether it’s over denied claims, low settlement offers, or unfair claim handling practices like bad faith. They understand insurance law and how to negotiate or sue insurance companies.