No, you cannot tow a car with the parking brake on. Doing so can cause significant damage to the vehicle, create a dangerous towing situation, and may even be illegal.
Towing a vehicle is a common necessity, whether it’s moving a broken-down car to a repair shop or transporting a classic car to a show. However, the specifics of how you tow can make a world of difference in the safety and integrity of both the towing vehicle and the towed vehicle. One of the most critical aspects to get right is how the parking brake is handled on the vehicle being towed. Many people wonder, “Can you tow a car with the parking brake engaged?” The short answer is a resounding no, and in this comprehensive guide, we’ll delve into why this is the case, the extensive risks involved, and the proper procedures for safe towing.
Image Source: i.imgur.com
The Fundamental Flaw: Why Engaging the Parking Brake is a Recipe for Disaster
The parking brake, often called the handbrake or e-brake, is designed to hold a vehicle stationary when parked. It typically applies braking force to the rear wheels, though some systems can affect all four. When towing, the wheels of the towed vehicle are meant to rotate freely. If the parking brake is engaged, it essentially locks those wheels.
What Happens If You Tow With Parking Brake On?
When you attempt to tow a car with its parking brake engaged, you are forcing the locked wheels to drag or skid along the ground. This creates immense friction and resistance. The consequences are immediate and often severe:
- Overheating and Damage: The friction generated will quickly cause the brake components – pads, rotors, and drums – to overheat. This can lead to warping of the rotors or drums, glazing of the brake pads, and even melting of brake fluid seals.
- Tire Wear and Damage: The tires will be subjected to extreme abrasion as they are forced to rotate while the brakes are applied. This can cause rapid, uneven tire wear, and in severe cases, lead to tire blowouts.
- Strain on the Towing Vehicle: The towing vehicle will have to exert significantly more force to overcome the resistance from the locked brakes. This puts tremendous strain on the drivetrain, transmission, and brakes of the towing vehicle.
- Loss of Control: The increased drag can make the towed vehicle unstable and difficult to control. This significantly elevates the risk of the towed vehicle swerving or fishtailing, potentially leading to an accident.
- Component Failure: Beyond the brakes and tires, the constant resistance can lead to failures in the suspension and even the axle components of the towed vehicle.
Risks of Towing a Car with the Parking Brake Engaged
The risks associated with towing a car with the parking brake engaged are substantial and far-reaching. They impact the towed vehicle, the towing vehicle, and everyone involved in the towing operation.
Damage From Towing With Parking Brake
The types of damage that can occur are varied and costly.
- Brake System Catastrophe: This is the most direct and often the most severe damage.
- Warped Rotors/Drums: Extreme heat causes metal to expand and contract unevenly, leading to warping.
- Burned Brake Pads: The friction material on the brake pads can be overheated, glazed, and rendered ineffective.
- Damaged Calipers/Wheel Cylinders: Overheating can damage the seals and components within the calipers (disc brakes) or wheel cylinders (drum brakes).
- Brake Fluid Contamination: In extreme cases, overheating can boil the brake fluid, introducing air and moisture, which compromises the entire braking system.
- Tire Ruin:
- Severe Sidewall Damage: The edges of the tires can be abraded and damaged.
- Tread Separation: The intense heat can weaken the bond between the tire layers, leading to dangerous tread separation.
- Complete Blowouts: The cumulative stress can cause a catastrophic tire failure.
- Drivetrain and Axle Stress:
- Transmission Overload: The transmission in the towed vehicle (if it’s an automatic and not in neutral) can be severely damaged by being forced to turn without proper lubrication or engagement.
- Axle Bearing Damage: The immense drag can put excessive stress on axle bearings, leading to premature wear or failure.
- Structural Damage: In severe cases, the forces involved could even cause minor structural damage to the frame or suspension mounting points.
Safety Hazards During Towing
Beyond mechanical damage, the safety implications are paramount.
- Loss of Towing Stability: The uneven resistance created by the engaged parking brake can cause the towed vehicle to fishtail or swerve, making it extremely difficult for the towing vehicle driver to maintain control.
- Brake Fade on Towing Vehicle: If the towed vehicle’s brakes are dragging severely, it can cause the towing vehicle’s brakes to overheat and fade due to the constant extra effort required.
- Increased Stopping Distances: The combined effect of the drag and potential brake fade significantly increases the stopping distance for the entire towing rig, posing a serious risk in emergency situations.
- Potential for Detachment: In extreme scenarios of component failure due to the strain, there’s a slim but terrifying possibility of the towed vehicle becoming detached from the towing vehicle.
Can You Legally Tow With Parking Brake On?
In most jurisdictions, attempting to tow a car with the parking brake engaged is not only unsafe but also illegal. It falls under operating a vehicle in an unsafe condition. Law enforcement officers would likely consider this a dangerous practice that endangers other road users. The specific laws vary, but the overarching principle is to ensure that any vehicle on the road, whether self-propelled or towed, is in a safe operating condition. Towing a car with parking brake on is universally frowned upon and likely prohibited.
Fathoming the Effects of Towing With Parking Brake
The effects of towing with parking brake are essentially a cascading series of failures triggered by excessive friction and resistance.
- Initial Friction and Heat: The moment towing begins, the parking brake creates friction. This friction converts kinetic energy into heat.
- Thermal Expansion and Deformation: As components heat up, they expand. Metal parts like rotors and drums can warp due to uneven expansion.
- Material Degradation: High temperatures can degrade the materials in brake pads, reducing their friction coefficient and lifespan. Rubber seals in the brake system can melt or fail.
- Mechanical Stress Accumulation: The constant force required to overcome the brake engagement stresses the entire axle, suspension, and drivetrain of the towed vehicle.
- Tire Degradation: The rubber of the tires is not designed to withstand sustained friction and heat from being dragged. It will begin to break down, leading to wear and potential failure.
What Happens If You Tow With Parking Brake? A Detailed Breakdown
Let’s break down the chain reaction when you attempt this dangerous maneuver:
- Initiation: Towing starts. The parking brake is still applied.
- Immediate Resistance: The towed wheels are locked or partially locked. The towing vehicle must pull against this resistance.
- Friction Generates Heat: The brake pads rub against the rotors/drums. Tires rub against the road surface.
- Overheating: Brake components quickly reach critical temperatures. Rotors/drums can glow red. Brake fluid can boil.
- Component Damage: Warping, glazing, and melting occur in the brake system. Tires begin to wear rapidly.
- Increased Strain: The towing vehicle’s engine and transmission work harder. The hitch and tow straps/chains are under immense stress.
- Instability: The towed vehicle’s movement becomes unpredictable due to uneven drag.
- Potential Failure: A tire blows, an axle breaks, or brake components fail catastrophically.
- Loss of Control or Accident: The rig becomes uncontrollable, leading to a crash.
Towing Safety Parking Brake: Best Practices for a Smooth Operation
Prioritizing towing safety parking brake management is crucial. The goal is to ensure the towed vehicle rolls freely without any unintended braking force.
Essential Towing Tips Parking Brake Management
Here are key towing tips parking brake awareness:
- Always Release the Parking Brake: This is the golden rule. Ensure the parking brake is fully disengaged before any towing begins.
- Verify Release: Don’t just assume it’s off. Visually check the brake lever or pedal, and physically try to push the car to confirm it rolls easily.
- Neutral Gear for Automatics: For vehicles with automatic transmissions, ensure the gear selector is in “Neutral.” This allows the transmission and drivetrain to rotate freely.
- Manual Transmission Neutral and Clutch In (Briefly): For manual transmissions, shift into Neutral. While some might suggest keeping the clutch pedal depressed, this isn’t always practical for long-distance towing. The primary goal is to have the transmission in neutral and the parking brake off.
- Consider Disconnecting Driveshaft/Axles: For certain towing methods, especially flat-towing (where all four wheels are on the ground), it’s often recommended or required by manufacturers to disconnect the driveshaft or rear axles to prevent drivetrain damage. This is especially true for vehicles with all-wheel drive or four-wheel drive systems.
- Check Owner’s Manual: Always consult the owner’s manual of the vehicle being towed. It will provide specific instructions regarding towing, including how to handle the parking brake and transmission.
Parking Brake in Neutral for Towing: The Correct Approach
The phrase “parking brake in neutral for towing” highlights two separate but equally important steps.
- Parking Brake: Must be fully released.
- Transmission: Must be in Neutral (N).
These two actions ensure that the wheels are free to rotate and that the drivetrain is not being forced to turn unnecessarily.
Towing Precautions Parking Brake: What to Check Before You Go
Taking towing precautions parking brake into account involves a pre-tow checklist.
Pre-Tow Checklist for the Towed Vehicle
- Parking Brake: Visually confirm the parking brake lever/pedal is in the “off” position.
- Transmission: Shift the transmission into Neutral (N).
- Ignition: For many vehicles, the ignition should be in the “Accessory” or “On” position (without starting the engine) to disengage steering wheel locks and power essential systems like lights. This is also crucial for ABS and taillight functionality on the towed vehicle. Check your owner’s manual.
- Steering Wheel: Ensure the steering wheel is unlocked. If the ignition is off and the steering wheel lock engages, the towed car will not follow the towing vehicle’s path, making towing impossible and dangerous.
- Lights: Ensure all required lights on the towed vehicle (brake lights, turn signals, taillights) are functional. This usually requires connecting the lights of the towed vehicle to the towing vehicle.
- Securement: Verify that the towing hitch, chains, straps, and any safety cables are properly attached and secured.
Towed Vehicle Parking Brake Issues: Common Problems and Solutions
Even with careful preparation, towed vehicle parking brake issues can arise.
Common Parking Brake Problems During Towing
- Sticking Parking Brake: Sometimes, even after releasing the lever/pedal, the brake shoes/pads may stick to the rotors/drums due to rust or debris.
- Solution: Gently tapping on the brake drum/rotor (if accessible) or slightly rocking the vehicle before towing can help dislodge minor sticking. If it’s a more persistent issue, professional inspection and repair are needed.
- Parking Brake Cables Binding: The cables that operate the parking brake can become corroded, kinked, or stretched, leading to improper operation.
- Solution: This requires adjustment or replacement of the parking brake cables. It’s a job best left to a mechanic.
- Automatic Parking Brake Engagement: Some modern vehicles have electronic parking brakes (EPB). Improper handling of these can lead to accidental engagement.
- Solution: Always consult the vehicle’s owner’s manual on how to properly disengage the EPB for towing. Sometimes, there’s a specific procedure involving the ignition and the EPB button.
Alternatives to Traditional Towing and Parking Brake Considerations
Different towing methods have varying implications for the parking brake.
Towing Methods and Parking Brake Implications
| Towing Method | Parking Brake Requirement | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Flat Towing | Must be fully released. Transmission in Neutral. | All four wheels are on the ground. This method puts the most stress on the drivetrain if not prepared correctly. Steering wheel must be unlocked. Requires auxiliary braking systems for safety and legality in many areas. Consult owner’s manual for RWD vs FWD vs AWD/4WD. |
| Dolly Towing | Must be fully released. Transmission in Neutral. | Front wheels are lifted onto the dolly. Rear wheels are on the ground. Parking brake often acts on the rear wheels, so releasing it is critical. This is generally safer for automatic transmissions than flat towing as the driven wheels are not rotating the transmission. |
| Car Carrier/Trailer | Must be fully released. Transmission in Neutral. | All four wheels are off the ground and resting on the trailer. This is the safest method as it completely isolates the towed vehicle’s drivetrain from rotation. However, the parking brake must still be released to prevent damage to the trailer’s braking system or strain on the vehicle itself. |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What if my car has an electronic parking brake (EPB)?
Cars with electronic parking brakes (EPBs) require a specific procedure to disengage them for towing. This usually involves turning the ignition to the “Accessory” or “On” position and then manually pressing the EPB release button. Always refer to your vehicle’s owner’s manual for the exact steps. Failure to disengage the EPB correctly can lead to damage similar to a manual parking brake.
Can I tow my car with the transmission in Park?
No, you should never tow a car with an automatic transmission in “Park.” This locks the transmission’s output shaft and will cause severe damage to the transmission and drivetrain. The transmission must be in “Neutral.” For manual transmissions, it’s also essential to be in Neutral.
What happens if the parking brake cable snaps while towing?
If the parking brake cable were to snap while towing and the brake was partially engaged, the resistance would suddenly be removed. However, if the brake components were already severely overheated and damaged, they might still function poorly or fail even without the cable. The primary danger is the damage incurred before the cable snaps.
Is it okay to leave the parking brake slightly engaged?
No, not even slightly engaged. Any engagement of the parking brake while towing will create unwanted friction and heat, leading to potential damage and safety hazards. The goal is complete release.
What are the risks of towing a car that I don’t know the condition of?
If you are unaware of the towed vehicle’s condition, it’s even more critical to follow all towing precautions. Pay extra attention to ensuring the parking brake is off and the transmission is in neutral. Assume the worst and be meticulous in your checks.
Conclusion: Prioritize Safety and Prevent Costly Repairs
In summary, attempting to tow a car with the parking brake engaged is a dangerous and damaging practice. The risks and safety implications are significant, ranging from ruined brake components and tires to compromised handling and the potential for accidents. By following proper towing safety parking brake procedures, understanding the effects of towing with parking brake, and adhering to towing tips parking brake best practices, you can ensure a safe and damage-free towing experience. Always remember to consult your vehicle’s owner’s manual and prioritize meticulous preparation before embarking on any towing operation.