How To Sue Car Insurance Company: Your Legal Steps Guide

You can sue a car insurance company if they do not pay your valid claim fairly or on time. This usually happens when they deny your claim, offer too little money, or cause long, unfair delays. Filing a lawsuit is a serious step and often comes after you have a denied car insurance claim or face insurance claim settlement disputes. You will likely need help from a lawyer to take legal action against the company.

Suing an insurance company is not easy. They have many lawyers who work to protect the company. But if they break their promise to you under the insurance policy, you have rights. This guide will explain the steps you can take if you believe your car insurance company is not treating you fairly.

How To Sue Car Insurance Company
Image Source: jknylaw.com

Why People Sue Car Insurance Companies

Most people buy car insurance to get help if something bad happens, like an accident. You pay premiums hoping the company will be there when you need them. But sometimes, the company does not live up to its end of the deal.

People usually sue an insurance company for a few main reasons:

Denied Car Insurance Claim: They say your claim is not covered by your policy or that the accident was your fault when it was not.
Lowball Settlement Offers: They offer you much less money than your claim is worth. This happens for repairs, medical bills, or other costs.
Unreasonable Delays: They take a very long time to handle your claim without a good reason. This can cause you money problems or stop you from getting repairs or medical care.
Bad Faith Actions: They act unfairly or dishonestly during the claim process. This is a serious issue and has special rules.

When these things happen, you might be in an insurance claim settlement disputes. You need to know your rights and what you can do next.

Grasping Why Claims May Go Wrong

Insurance companies are businesses. They make money by collecting premiums and pay out money for claims. They want to pay as little as possible on each claim to protect their profits. This is not always a bad thing; they need to check claims to prevent fraud. But sometimes, this goal makes them treat policyholders unfairly.

Here are common reasons why a car insurance claim might face problems:

Policy Rules: The company might say your claim is not covered based on specific words or limits in your insurance policy. This can feel unfair if you thought you were covered.
Not Enough Proof: They might say you did not provide enough evidence to show the damage, your injuries, or who was at fault.
Disagreement on Fault: If the accident involves other drivers, the companies might not agree on who caused it. Your company might say you were partly or fully to blame to reduce the amount they owe.
Disagreement on Value: They might offer less than what repairs cost, or less than your car was worth if it was totaled. They might also argue about how much your medical treatment should cost or how long you need it.
Paperwork and Process Issues: Missing forms, mistakes on forms, or simply losing paperwork can cause delays or denials.

Sometimes, these issues are honest mistakes or disagreements. But other times, they can be signs the company is acting improperly, possibly leading to a breach of insurance contract or a bad faith insurance claim. A breach of insurance contract means the company did not do what the policy promised it would do.

Exploring Your Choices Before Filing a Lawsuit

Suing an insurance company is often the last step. It takes a lot of time and can be stressful. There are other things you can try first to solve the insurance claim settlement disputes. These steps might help you get a fair outcome without going to court.

Talking More with the Adjuster and Supervisor

Your first point of contact is usually the insurance adjuster. If you disagree with their decision or offer, talk to them. Ask for a clear, written reason for their denial or low offer. Use simple language to state why you disagree. Provide more evidence if you can.

If the adjuster does not help, ask to speak to their supervisor or manager. They might have more power to review your case or offer a better settlement. Be polite but firm. Keep records of all your talks, including dates, times, names, and what was said.

Filing a Complaint with the State Insurance Department

Every state has a department that oversees insurance companies. They make sure companies follow state laws. If you think your insurer is acting unfairly or breaking rules, you can filing complaint against insurance company with this department.

Here is what filing a complaint usually involves:

Getting the complaint form from your state’s insurance department website.
Filling out the form with details about your claim, the company’s actions, and why you think they are wrong.
Sending copies of important papers, like your policy, denial letters, repair estimates, or medical bills.

What the state department does:

They review your complaint.
They contact the insurance company and ask for their side of the story.
They might investigate if the company broke state insurance laws.
They might help mediate or guide the talks.

Important: The state insurance department usually cannot force the company to pay your claim or pay a certain amount. They can only make sure the company followed the rules in handling the claim. If the company broke rules, the state might fine them or take other action, but it does not directly get you money. However, a state complaint can sometimes make the company take your claim more seriously.

Getting Help from a Lawyer Early

Even before you decide to sue, it is smart to talk to a lawyer who handles insurance disputes. A good insurance dispute lawyer can look at your case and tell you your legal options insurance claim. They can tell you if the company acted unfairly, if you have a strong case, and what the next steps might be.

A lawyer can also help you:

Gather more evidence for your claim.
Write strong letters to the insurance company demanding proper payment.
Negotiate with the company on your behalf.
Explain your rights under your specific policy and state laws.

Talking to a lawyer early can often help settle the claim without a lawsuit. If it does go to court, they are ready to guide you. Many lawyers offer a free first talk, so it costs nothing to find out where you stand.

Deciphering Bad Faith Insurance Claims

Sometimes, an insurance company does not just make a mistake or disagree with you. Sometimes, they act in a way that is dishonest or unfair on purpose. This is called acting in “bad faith.” A bad faith insurance claim is a claim against the insurance company itself, saying they handled your original claim unfairly.

Insurance companies have a duty to act in “good faith” towards their policyholders. This means they must handle your claim fairly, honestly, and promptly. When they fail to do this, they might be acting in bad faith.

What counts as bad faith behavior?

Not investigating your claim properly or quickly.
Denying a claim without a good reason or based on facts they know are wrong.
Offering much less than the claim is clearly worth, knowing the offer is too low.
Refusing to pay a claim unless you accept less than the full amount owed.
Not telling you the real reason they denied your claim.
Making you provide endless amounts of unneeded paperwork.
Threatening you or using pressure to make you give up your claim.
Changing the reason for denying the claim over time.
Delaying the process without a valid reason to try and make you give up.

Every state has car insurance bad faith laws. These laws define what bad faith is in that state and what policyholders can do about it. If a court finds an insurance company acted in bad faith, you might be able to recovering damages from insurance company beyond what your original claim was worth.

Why Bad Faith is Different

Suing for bad faith is different from suing for breach of insurance contract.
* A breach of insurance contract claim says the company did not pay what the policy said they should. You are asking for the money owed under the policy.
* A bad faith insurance claim says the company acted wrongly in how they handled your claim. You are asking for the money owed on the claim plus other money because they treated you unfairly. This extra money can include damages for the harm their bad faith caused (like stress or financial loss) and sometimes even punishment damages (punitive damages) to punish the company.

Proving bad faith is hard. It requires showing the company knew they were acting unfairly or did not care if they did. This is why you need a lawyer who understands car insurance bad faith laws.

The Lawsuit Process: Grasping the Steps

If other options do not work, and you have a strong case, your insurance dispute lawyer might advise you to file a lawsuit. Suing an insurance company involves following set legal steps. This is the car insurance company lawsuit process.

Here are the typical steps involved in a lawsuit against a car insurance company:

h4: Step 1: Hiring a Lawyer

This is a crucial first step. Fighting an insurance company alone is very difficult. You need a lawyer experienced in insurance law and accident claims. They know the rules, the tactics insurance companies use, and how to build a strong case. Many work on a contingency fee, meaning they only get paid if you win or settle.

h4: Step 2: Investigation and Gathering Evidence

Your lawyer will fully investigate your case. They will look at:

Your insurance policy details.
The facts of the accident.
Police reports.
Witness statements.
Photos and videos of the scene and damages.
Repair estimates.
Your medical records and bills.
Any communication you had with the insurance company (letters, emails, notes on phone calls).
Internal notes or records from the insurance company (obtained later in the process).

They will gather all proof to show the company was wrong to deny your claim or offer too little. If you are claiming bad faith, they will look for proof of the company’s unfair actions.

h4: Step 3: Filing the Complaint

This is the official start of the lawsuit. Your lawyer will prepare a document called a “Complaint” or “Petition.” This document tells the court:

Who you are.
Who you are suing (the insurance company).
What happened (the accident, the claim, the company’s actions).
Why you believe the company is wrong (e.g., breach of insurance contract, negligence in handling the claim, bad faith insurance claim).
What you are asking the court for (the money for your damages).

The Complaint is filed with the proper court, and the insurance company is formally notified that they are being sued. This is part of the car insurance company lawsuit process.

h4: Step 4: The Company’s Answer

After being served, the insurance company has a set time to respond to the Complaint. Their lawyers will file an “Answer” with the court. In the Answer, they will usually deny most or all of your claims. This sets up the issues the court will need to decide.

h4: Step 5: Discovery

This phase is where both sides exchange information and evidence. It can take many months. Common parts of Discovery include:

Interrogatories: Written questions that the other side must answer under oath.
Requests for Production: Demands for documents, photos, emails, and other records. This is how your lawyer might get internal company claim files.
Depositions: Out-of-court sworn testimony. Lawyers ask questions to you, the adjuster, witnesses, doctors, and anyone else involved. A court reporter writes down everything said.
Requests for Admission: Asking the other side to admit certain facts are true.

Discovery is key to building your case and finding out the strengths and weaknesses of the insurance company’s position. If you claim bad faith, discovery is vital for finding proof of their unfair handling.

h4: Step 6: Motions

During discovery, lawyers might file motions with the court. A “motion” is a request for the judge to do something. For example, a lawyer might ask the judge to force the other side to hand over documents they are refusing to share. Or the company might ask the judge to dismiss part or all of your case.

h4: Step 7: Mediation or Settlement Talks

Most lawsuits settle before going to trial. At some point, often after discovery, both sides usually try to reach an agreement.

Direct Negotiation: Lawyers talk to each other to see if they can agree on a settlement amount.
Mediation: A neutral third person (a mediator) meets with both sides and their lawyers. The mediator does not make a decision but helps the parties talk and try to find a solution. This is a common step before trial.

If a settlement is reached, the case ends. You receive the agreed-upon money, and you drop the lawsuit.

h4: Step 8: Trial

If no settlement is reached, the case goes to trial. This is where both sides present their evidence to a judge or jury.

Lawyers give opening statements.
They call witnesses to testify (you, experts, adjusters).
They show evidence (photos, documents, medical bills).
Lawyers give closing statements.
The judge or jury makes a decision (a verdict) and says who wins and how much money, if any, should be paid (recovering damages from insurance company).

Trials are complex, public, and can take days or weeks.

h4: Step 9: Appeal

If one side disagrees with the trial outcome, they might be able to appeal to a higher court. This adds more time and cost to the process.

This car insurance company lawsuit process shows why having a insurance dispute lawyer is essential. They guide you through these complex steps.

Recovering Damages from the Insurance Company

If you win your lawsuit or reach a settlement, the money you receive is called “damages.” The goal of recovering damages from insurance company is to put you back in the financial position you were in before the accident and before the company mishandled your claim, as much as possible.

What kind of damages can you recover?

h4: Damages Related to the Original Claim

This is the money you should have received under your insurance policy for your accident losses. This can include:

Cost to repair or replace your car.
Money for medical bills (past and future).
Money for lost wages if you could not work because of injuries.
Money for pain and suffering caused by your injuries.
Other costs directly related to the accident (like rental car costs).

h4: Damages Related to Bad Faith (If Applicable)

If you also proved that the insurance company acted in bad faith insurance claim, you might be able to recover additional damages. These can include:

Consequential Damages: Money for other losses you suffered because of their delay or denial. For example, if you lost your job because you could not afford medical treatment the company should have paid for, you might get money for those lost wages.
Emotional Distress: Money for the stress, anxiety, and emotional harm caused by the company’s bad faith actions.
Attorney Fees and Costs: In many states with car insurance bad faith laws, the company might have to pay your lawyer’s fees and other costs of bringing the lawsuit, which can be very high.
Punitive Damages: In some cases where the company’s bad faith was extreme or malicious, a court might award punitive damages. This money is meant to punish the company and stop them and other companies from doing the same thing again. Punitive damages can be much larger than the original claim amount.

The amount of damages you can seek depends on your specific case, the details of the company’s actions, your policy limits, and your state’s car insurance bad faith laws.

Your Legal Pathways for an Insurance Claim

When your car insurance claim hits a wall – maybe it’s a denied car insurance claim or insurance claim settlement disputes – you have several legal options insurance claim holders can explore. These pathways range from talking it out to going to court.

Here is a look at the different paths you can take:

Continuing Negotiations: Keep talking with the insurance company adjuster or their manager. Present more facts, doctors’ notes, or repair estimates. Try to reach a fair deal.
Internal Appeals: Some companies have their own process for you to ask for a review of a denial.
Filing a State Complaint: You can try filing complaint against insurance company with your state’s department of insurance. They can investigate the company’s actions.
Mediation or Arbitration: These are ways to solve problems outside of court.
- Mediation: A neutral person helps you and the company talk to find a solution. You both must agree on the answer.
- Arbitration: A neutral person or a small group hears both sides and makes a decision. This decision is often binding, meaning you must follow it. Your policy might require arbitration for some disputes.
Filing a Lawsuit (Litigation): This is the formal process of going to court. You file a complaint, exchange information (discovery), and possibly have a trial. You can sue for breach of insurance contract (they didn’t pay what was owed) or for bad faith insurance claim (they handled the claim wrongly), or both.
Bad Faith Lawsuit: If the company acted very unfairly or dishonestly, you can file a separate lawsuit claiming bad faith insurance claim. This allows you to seek extra damages beyond your original claim amount.

Choosing the right pathway depends on your situation, how the company acted, the amount of money involved, and your willingness to go through a legal process. Talking to a hire insurance dispute lawyer is the best way to figure out which path is right for you.

Picking a Good Insurance Dispute Lawyer

If you decide to take legal action, or even just need advice, you need a lawyer who knows how to handle insurance companies. Not all lawyers are the same. You want one with experience in insurance claim settlement disputes and car insurance bad faith laws.

Here is what to look for when you hire insurance dispute lawyer:

Experience with Insurance Cases: Ask how many cases they have handled against insurance companies. Have they gone to trial against insurers? Do they understand bad faith law in your state?
Focus Area: Does the lawyer or their firm focus on insurance law, personal injury, or consumer rights? These areas often deal with insurance disputes.
Track Record: Have they had success getting fair results for clients against insurance companies? They cannot promise a result, but they should show a history of positive outcomes.
How They Charge: Most lawyers handling these cases work on a contingency fee. This means they take a percentage of the money you win or settle for. If you lose, you usually do not pay them attorney fees. Make sure you understand this agreement fully. Ask about other costs you might have to pay (filing fees, expert witness fees, etc.).
Communication: Do they explain things in a way you understand? Do they listen to you? Will they keep you updated on your case?
References: Ask for references from past clients or other lawyers.
Comfort Level: Do you feel comfortable talking openly with them? You will be sharing personal information.

Take time to meet with a few lawyers before you decide. Many offer free first meetings. This lets you ask questions and see if they are a good fit for your case.

Table: Comparing Legal Pathways

Here is a simple look at some of the legal options insurance claim holders have when facing issues:

Pathway	Description	Cost (Usually)	Time (Usually)	Outcome Control	Need a Lawyer?
Negotiation	Directly talking with the company adjuster/manager to reach a deal.	Free (Your time)	Days to Weeks	High (If you agree)	Helpful, but not always needed
State Complaint	Asking the state insurance department to review the company’s actions.	Free	Weeks to Months	Low (Cannot force payment)	No, usually DIY
Mediation	A neutral person helps talks to find a solution; you agree to the deal.	Shared fee for mediator	Hours to Days	High (If you agree)	Helpful, recommended
Arbitration	A neutral person or panel hears case and makes a decision (often binding).	Often shared costs	Months	Low (Third party decides)	Yes, recommended
Lawsuit (Litigation)	Filing a formal case in court to get a judge/jury decision.	High (But lawyer often contingency)	Months to Years	Low (Court decides)	Yes, usually essential
Bad Faith Lawsuit	Suing the company for acting unfairly/dishonestly in handling claim.	High (But lawyer often contingency)	Months to Years	Low (Court decides)	Yes, essential

What if the Company Offers a Settlement During the Process?

The insurance company might offer you money at different times: before you sue, after you file a complaint, or during the lawsuit. Any offer should be looked at very carefully with your lawyer.

Is the offer fair? Does it cover all your costs and losses?
Does it cover future costs? If you have ongoing medical needs, does the offer account for that?
Does it resolve all your claims? If you believe they acted in bad faith, does the offer include money for that?

Your lawyer will help you understand if a settlement offer is reasonable. They can advise you on whether to accept it, reject it, or make a counteroffer. If you accept a settlement, you will have to sign papers that say you cannot sue the company later for the same claim.

Preparing for a Lawsuit

If you and your lawyer decide to sue, be ready for a process that takes time and effort.

Gather Your Records: Keep copies of everything – policy papers, claim numbers, letters from the company, your notes from phone calls, repair bills, medical records, photos, police reports. Organize them.
Be Patient: Lawsuits move slowly. There are many steps, and getting court dates can take time.
Work Closely with Your Lawyer: Answer their questions quickly, provide documents they ask for, and be honest about all the facts.
Understand the Risks: There is no guarantee you will win. Lawsuits can be stressful. Your lawyer will discuss the possible good and bad outcomes.

Filing a car insurance company lawsuit process is a major step, but it is sometimes necessary to get the money you are owed.

Conclusion

Dealing with a denied car insurance claim or insurance claim settlement disputes can be frustrating and financially difficult. While suing your car insurance company is a significant action, it is one of your legal options insurance claim if the company treats you unfairly or breaches its contract.

Before rushing to court, explore all possibilities, like trying to negotiate more, filing a complaint with the state, or considering mediation. If these steps do not work or if you believe the company acted in bad faith insurance claim, consulting with a hire insurance dispute lawyer is highly recommended.

A lawyer can help you understand your rights, assess the strength of your case, and guide you through the complex car insurance company lawsuit process. They can help you seek recovering damages from insurance company that are owed to you under your policy, and potentially extra damages if the company violated car insurance bad faith laws.

Fighting an insurance company can be hard, but you do not have to do it alone. Knowing your rights and getting the right legal help is key to seeking a fair outcome.

Frequently Asked Questions

h3: How long does it take to sue a car insurance company?

It varies a lot. Some cases settle quickly after a lawsuit is filed (a few months). Others, especially complex ones or those that go to trial, can take a year or two, or even longer. It depends on the case facts, the court’s schedule, and how willing the company is to settle.

h3: How much does it cost to sue an insurance company?

Lawsuits can be expensive due to court fees, costs for getting documents, paying expert witnesses, etc. However, most lawyers handling these cases work on a contingency fee basis. This means their fee is a percentage of the money you win or settle for. You typically only pay the lawyer if you get money. You might still have to pay for other case costs, even if you lose, but discuss this clearly with your lawyer first.

h3: Can I sue my car insurance company without a lawyer?

You have the right to represent yourself. However, suing an insurance company is very complex. Insurance companies have experienced lawyers. You need to know legal rules, court procedures, and insurance laws. It is very difficult to succeed without a lawyer who understands these things. Hiring a hire insurance dispute lawyer is strongly recommended.

h3: What is the difference between a breach of contract and a bad faith claim?

Breach of insurance contract means the company did not follow the policy rules, like failing to pay a valid claim. You seek the money owed under the policy. A bad faith insurance claim means the company acted unfairly or dishonestly in handling your claim. You seek the money owed plus extra damages because of their bad actions.

h3: Can I sue for more than my policy limits?

Usually, a claim for breach of insurance contract is limited to the policy limits. However, if you win a bad faith insurance claim, you might be able to recover damages beyond your policy limits, as well as possible attorney fees and punitive damages in some states, depending on the car insurance bad faith laws.

h3: Will suing my insurance company make my rates go up or cause them to cancel me?

Insurance companies cannot legally raise your rates or cancel your policy just because you filed a complaint or lawsuit against them for a claim. However, your rates might increase based on the accident itself, your driving record, or other factors unrelated to the lawsuit. If you believe they raised rates or cancelled you because you sued, you should talk to your lawyer and possibly file another complaint with the state insurance department.